Taste Test: Chipotle vs Subway's Best Menu Items

Join us for a taste test of Chipotle and Subway's best menu items. Find out which brand comes out on top in flavor and satisfaction.

Published: 8/27/20254 min read
Author avatar
Avery Cole
Senior Editor, DuelVote

Have a preference in this matchup?

Vote: Chipotle or Subway

Add your voice and instantly see the live crowd split. No sign up.

Cast your vote

Live picks: Chipotle 0 (0%) · Subway 1,008 (100%)

Introduction

In the fast-casual dining landscape, Chipotle and Subway stand out as two popular choices for consumers seeking quick, customizable meals. Both brands have carved out their niches, offering distinct flavors and dining experiences. This article aims to compare Chipotle and Subway by evaluating their best menu items in terms of flavor, customer satisfaction, nutritional value, and overall dining experience.

Overview of Chipotle and Subway

Chipotle

Founded in 1993, Chipotle Mexican Grill has become synonymous with fresh, high-quality Mexican cuisine. The brand prides itself on using responsibly sourced ingredients, including hormone-free meat and organic produce. Chipotle's menu revolves around customizable burritos, bowls, tacos, and salads, allowing customers to tailor their meals to their preferences.

Subway

Subway, established in 1965, is renowned for its submarine sandwiches and salads. With a focus on freshness and customization, Subway allows customers to choose from a wide variety of breads, meats, cheeses, and toppings. The brand's tagline, "Eat Fresh," emphasizes its commitment to providing healthier fast-food options.

Flavor Profiles

When it comes to flavor, both Chipotle and Subway offer unique experiences that cater to different taste preferences.

Chipotle's Flavor

Chipotle's menu features bold flavors, primarily influenced by Mexican cuisine. Signature ingredients such as cilantro-lime rice, smoky chipotle peppers, and fresh pico de gallo create a vibrant taste profile. The brand's emphasis on fresh ingredients contributes to the overall flavor intensity. Popular menu items include:

Burrito

A customizable wrap filled with your choice of protein, rice, beans, and toppings.

Bowl

Similar to the burrito but served in a bowl without the tortilla, allowing for a more substantial meal.

Tacos

Soft or crispy tacos filled with the same customizable ingredients.

Subway's Flavor

Subway's offerings lean towards a more traditional sandwich flavor profile, with a variety of meats, cheeses, and sauces that can be combined to create a personalized sandwich experience. The brand’s fresh vegetables add crunch and brightness to its sandwiches. Notable menu items include:

Submarine Sandwich

A classic sandwich that can be customized with various meats, cheeses, and toppings.

Salads

Fresh greens topped with a choice of proteins and dressings, offering a lighter option.

Wraps

A sandwich wrapped in a tortilla, providing a different texture and flavor experience.

Customer Satisfaction

Customer satisfaction is a crucial factor when comparing Chipotle and Subway. Both brands have their loyal fan bases, but their satisfaction ratings can vary based on individual preferences.

Chipotle's Satisfaction Ratings

Chipotle often receives praise for its flavor and quality of ingredients. Many customers appreciate the ability to customize their meals, which allows for a personalized dining experience. However, Chipotle has faced challenges related to food safety in the past, which has impacted some customers’ perceptions. Overall, Chipotle tends to score high in flavor satisfaction, with many customers returning for their favorite items.

Subway's Satisfaction Ratings

Subway enjoys a reputation for providing a healthier fast-food option, which appeals to health-conscious consumers. Customers often appreciate the variety of choices available, allowing for customization based on dietary preferences. However, some customers feel that the flavor can vary significantly depending on the location and the freshness of the ingredients. Despite this, Subway remains a popular choice for those seeking quick, customizable meals.

Nutritional Options

In today’s health-conscious environment, nutritional value is a significant consideration for many diners. Both Chipotle and Subway offer options that cater to various dietary needs.

Chipotle's Nutritional Offerings

Chipotle provides transparency regarding its ingredients, allowing customers to make informed choices. The brand offers several options for those following specific diets, including:

Vegetarian and Vegan

Options such as sofritas (tofu) and a variety of vegetables.

Gluten-Free

Most of Chipotle’s menu is gluten-free, aside from the flour tortillas.

Nutritional Information

Chipotle provides detailed nutritional information on its website, helping customers make choices aligned with their health goals.

Subway's Nutritional Offerings

Subway is well-known for its healthier alternatives, featuring a variety of low-calorie and low-fat options. The brand offers:

Fresh Vegetables

A wide selection of toppings to increase the nutritional value of any sandwich.

Low-Calorie Options

The “Subway Fresh Fit” menu includes sandwiches with 400 calories or less.

Nutritional Information

Similar to Chipotle, Subway provides nutritional information for its menu items, aiding customers in making healthier choices.

Pricing and Value

Pricing is another important factor when comparing Chipotle and Subway. Both brands aim to offer value for money, but the price points and portion sizes can differ.

Chipotle Pricing

Chipotle’s menu tends to be priced slightly higher than that of Subway, reflecting the quality of ingredients and the customizable nature of its offerings. A typical burrito or bowl can range from $8 to $12, depending on the selected ingredients.

Subway Pricing

Subway generally offers more affordable options, with prices for sandwiches typically ranging from $5 to $10. The variety of sizes and options allows customers to choose according to their budget.

Conclusion

In the battle of Chipotle versus Subway, both brands have their strengths and weaknesses. Chipotle excels in flavor and quality, appealing to those who enjoy bold, Mexican-inspired meals. On the other hand, Subway offers a more traditional sandwich experience with a focus on health and customization. Ultimately, the choice between Chipotle and Subway comes down to personal preference, dietary needs, and the type of dining experience one is seeking. Whether you prefer the vibrant flavors of Chipotle or the fresh options at Subway, both brands provide satisfying meals that cater to a wide range of tastes.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to articles